TJT2
2017-01-28 04:52:35 UTC
Viime syksynä Pekka de Groot halusi ihan välttämättä keskustella Chelmnosta,
mutta heti kun heitin Daltonia, P de G tunnusti keskustelun käyvän liian
kuumaksi ja luikki karkuun, väitettyään että Mattognolla ei ole muuta
perustetta kuin että raportti on puolainen. Vaan oikeastihan Mattognolla on
taas fysiikkaa ja matematiikkaa, joten Pekalle kävi taas zimmermanit
x x x clip x x x
The system described by the witnesses (particularly by M. Zurawski)
is nothing other than the so-called Feist apparatus, an oven for burning
carcasses of animals which have died of infectious diseases. It was
developed by veterinarian Georg Feist in the second half of
the nineteenth century. A book on cremation from the turn of the
century explains its structure and operation with the aid of a drawing
(de Cristoforis 1890, pp. 125-128; see document 11):
"This apparatus was originally designed by Dr. Feist for the sole
hygienic purpose of destroying the carcasses of animals which had
died of infectious diseases, but it is easy to understand that, with the
desired modifications, it can also be used to incinerate human remains
in the case of a significant mortality, such as in case of war or
during an epidemic, when the number of victims, the lack of time or
money does not permit a crematorium to be built, and finally in all
the circumstances that captain Rey has seen when he conceived his
mobile crematorium.
(sinpattu pitkä kuvaus laitteesta)
The complete combustion takes 5 to 6 hours for small animals
and 8 to 9 for bigger ones, which weigh 250 to 500 kg, which
amounts to 4-8 corpses of an average weight of 60 kg each.
At this time, moreover, everything is reduced completely, leaving
an ash residue of 1 to 2.5 kg.[72]
The employee responsible for conducting the cremation receives
20 Swiss francs per carcass, but is obliged to provide all the fuel,
and thus earns about half the sum. Fuel consumption is about 500-
600 kg of coal, 5-10 liters of oil and about 75 hundredweight of
straw and firewood."
In summary, the Feist apparatus had the shape of a truncated inverted
cone and a hearth grate of 90 cm in diameter with a surface area of
(pii×r² ) 0.64 square meters; in eight to nine hours it could incinerate
animal carcasses weighing some 250 to 500 kg, which is equivalent to
four to eight corpses of 60 kg, while consuming about 500 to 600 kg of
coal and five to ten liters of gasoline. Assuming average values, this
results in 375 kg of organic matter (the equivalent of six corpses)
incinerated in 8.5 hours using 550 kg of coal. In 24 hours, therefore,
the cremation capacity of the oven was 1,050 kg of organic matter
(the equivalent of 18 corpses) consuming 1,550 kg of coal.
In contrast to this, the Chelmno ovens are said to have had a rectangular
cross section and were allegedly equipped with a grate of 1.5 m ×
2 m = 3 m². A system of this kind therefore would have had a combustion
capacity (3÷0.6=) 5 times higher, therefore (18 × 5 =) 90 corpses in
24 hours, while consuming 7,750 kg of coal.
Zurawski's claim that a layer of 12 corpses burned in 15 minutes73 is
therefore crazy. In such a case, one oven alone would burn 1,152 corpses
in 24 hours, which is absurd. Instead, the theoretical capacity of the
two incinerators at Chelmno would have been 180 corpses in 24 hours.
But in practice, since the two ovens were fuelled with green wood according
to witnesses, which has a calorific value much lower than that
of coal,74 the actual combustion capacity would have been considerably
lower.
But even the theoretical maximum capacity of 180 corpses in 24
hours was inadequate even for an ostensible extermination camp like
Chelmno with its relatively limited influx of victims
(snipattu jutut Blobelista jne)
Archaeological excavations carried out by the Poles in the late 1980s
and early 1990s, however, disproved the report accepted by Judge Bednarz:
they found only the ruins of a single crematorium, which had a
maximum surface area of 6 m × 5 m, not 6 m × 10 m (see chapter 10),
and therefore had a grate in proportion of 1.5 square meters and a cremation
capacity of 45 corpses per 24 hours. This fact completely demolishes
any claim that Chelmno was an extermination camp.
x x x clop x x x
23-c.pdf, sivut 86 - 89
mutta heti kun heitin Daltonia, P de G tunnusti keskustelun käyvän liian
kuumaksi ja luikki karkuun, väitettyään että Mattognolla ei ole muuta
perustetta kuin että raportti on puolainen. Vaan oikeastihan Mattognolla on
taas fysiikkaa ja matematiikkaa, joten Pekalle kävi taas zimmermanit
x x x clip x x x
The system described by the witnesses (particularly by M. Zurawski)
is nothing other than the so-called Feist apparatus, an oven for burning
carcasses of animals which have died of infectious diseases. It was
developed by veterinarian Georg Feist in the second half of
the nineteenth century. A book on cremation from the turn of the
century explains its structure and operation with the aid of a drawing
(de Cristoforis 1890, pp. 125-128; see document 11):
"This apparatus was originally designed by Dr. Feist for the sole
hygienic purpose of destroying the carcasses of animals which had
died of infectious diseases, but it is easy to understand that, with the
desired modifications, it can also be used to incinerate human remains
in the case of a significant mortality, such as in case of war or
during an epidemic, when the number of victims, the lack of time or
money does not permit a crematorium to be built, and finally in all
the circumstances that captain Rey has seen when he conceived his
mobile crematorium.
(sinpattu pitkä kuvaus laitteesta)
The complete combustion takes 5 to 6 hours for small animals
and 8 to 9 for bigger ones, which weigh 250 to 500 kg, which
amounts to 4-8 corpses of an average weight of 60 kg each.
At this time, moreover, everything is reduced completely, leaving
an ash residue of 1 to 2.5 kg.[72]
The employee responsible for conducting the cremation receives
20 Swiss francs per carcass, but is obliged to provide all the fuel,
and thus earns about half the sum. Fuel consumption is about 500-
600 kg of coal, 5-10 liters of oil and about 75 hundredweight of
straw and firewood."
In summary, the Feist apparatus had the shape of a truncated inverted
cone and a hearth grate of 90 cm in diameter with a surface area of
(pii×r² ) 0.64 square meters; in eight to nine hours it could incinerate
animal carcasses weighing some 250 to 500 kg, which is equivalent to
four to eight corpses of 60 kg, while consuming about 500 to 600 kg of
coal and five to ten liters of gasoline. Assuming average values, this
results in 375 kg of organic matter (the equivalent of six corpses)
incinerated in 8.5 hours using 550 kg of coal. In 24 hours, therefore,
the cremation capacity of the oven was 1,050 kg of organic matter
(the equivalent of 18 corpses) consuming 1,550 kg of coal.
In contrast to this, the Chelmno ovens are said to have had a rectangular
cross section and were allegedly equipped with a grate of 1.5 m ×
2 m = 3 m². A system of this kind therefore would have had a combustion
capacity (3÷0.6=) 5 times higher, therefore (18 × 5 =) 90 corpses in
24 hours, while consuming 7,750 kg of coal.
Zurawski's claim that a layer of 12 corpses burned in 15 minutes73 is
therefore crazy. In such a case, one oven alone would burn 1,152 corpses
in 24 hours, which is absurd. Instead, the theoretical capacity of the
two incinerators at Chelmno would have been 180 corpses in 24 hours.
But in practice, since the two ovens were fuelled with green wood according
to witnesses, which has a calorific value much lower than that
of coal,74 the actual combustion capacity would have been considerably
lower.
But even the theoretical maximum capacity of 180 corpses in 24
hours was inadequate even for an ostensible extermination camp like
Chelmno with its relatively limited influx of victims
(snipattu jutut Blobelista jne)
Archaeological excavations carried out by the Poles in the late 1980s
and early 1990s, however, disproved the report accepted by Judge Bednarz:
they found only the ruins of a single crematorium, which had a
maximum surface area of 6 m × 5 m, not 6 m × 10 m (see chapter 10),
and therefore had a grate in proportion of 1.5 square meters and a cremation
capacity of 45 corpses per 24 hours. This fact completely demolishes
any claim that Chelmno was an extermination camp.
x x x clop x x x
23-c.pdf, sivut 86 - 89
--
--TJT--
I know no greater pleasure, no deeper satisfaction than to speak the truth.
--TJT--
I know no greater pleasure, no deeper satisfaction than to speak the truth.